Yeah, it’s depressing how much of wasted potential the criterion dungeons are. They fill a nice niche of 4 player hard content and being generally somewhere between extreme and savage, but the fact that the rewards are garbage mean most raiders aren’t ever going back in after their first clear solely for the experience. All content sorely needs rewards to bring people back in to keep it alive and criterion dungeons are doing the absolute worst of all content except maybe rival wings.

This is definitely interesting and I look forward to see how it plays.

At the same time, I remain slightly skeptical, as big brand name tie-in products often tend to be less than stellar. It takes a lot of effort, testing and polishing to put out at truly good TTRPG system and it’s not easy even for big companies that are dedicated to the industry. I’d love to see this succeed and continue to get extra material in the future, but at same time I’ve seen one too many fail trying to do things like this.

Brings to mind the Dark Souls TTRPG book built on top of D&D 5e, which was a thick tome absolutely chock full of gorgeus art and just as full of baffling, contradictory and clearly not at all playtested rules. Such a shame.

Yeah FF6 has Relm, whose ability “sketch” lets her copy enemies’ attacks by drawing them with a brush. It’s fairly similar to blue mage in its original form, but I highly doubt they’d make a second, highly similar limited. So I suspect it’s a lot like blue mage in its style except it’s a real job.

Previously Yoshi P’s shirt clues have not been particularly complicated so I think this solution makes the most sense so far.

They already revealed the job is a caster, not physical ranged, though.

And that works well when you have Discord for instant, synchronous messaging and voice chat and something like Reddit or another forum for more permanent, asynchronous discussions. Now that Reddit’s going the way of Digg, people are looking for anything to replace its functionality. Discord gets close, but isn’t quite there for the countless reasons already mentioned in this thread. That’s why I really hope something like this community on Fediverse takes off.

I believe this is the most populated FFXIV Community.

It’s the only one in existence I can find using the community search, at least. I’d love to see it grow.

I don’t think it’s even trying to, it’s just the users that see nails everywhere after getting a shiny new hammer. Discord is an excellent instant messenger & voice chat app, but it’s in no way a Reddit or forum replacement. They’ve added threads but again, those work more for containing conversations that veered off the original topic or are too specific for a channel, not as a replacement for something like a Reddit post.