I use manjaro linux and I installed brave using the AUR repo. I keep hearing stories about how Brave is just another ad tracking software like Chrome. What I don’t understand is why, like specifically.
Because I downloaded Brave from here. The code for Brave is here. I can build and install Brave and it will be the same as from AUR right?
Ok let me list my questions:
- If the sourcecode for Brave is open and is all I need to compile and run the software then where’s the tracker. The code base is honestly to big and high level for me and my professional abilities but I’m not that great of a programmer, I’m just really good. If there are ad trackers or adblock-blockers then I should beable to see it in the code right? I just need help actually seeing these lines of code.
- I’ve used wireshark to monitor Brave in isolation and I couldn’t see traffic that I would disapprove of. It is also very realistic that I just don’t know how to recognize.
- Just because Google maintains chromium doesn’t mean that chromium browsers have to track you. Chromium is opensource and it shouldn’t cost much to comment out trackers. So wasn’t this already done? And if not can we actually see the lines of code that track us?
Really what I’m looking for is help coming to the conclusion that these browsers are that bad for me myself.
Long time Brave user here! This list of chromium features changed for privacy reasons may ease your fears. One of the founders of Brave, Brendan Eich, was actually CTO of Mozilla (firefox) for a time, as well as the creator of the JavaScript programming language used in web development. One of the large reasons he left to found Brave was that he became disenfranchised with unethical handling of user data. Before the first line of Brave code was written it was dedicated to providing a safe, private user experience.
All the claims that say Brave isn’t a privacy-respecting browser are false because all the available data proves otherwise
They hate the company and ignore all the information that says it is a good browser, they can’t judge it objectively, it is like hating someone because you hate their “bad” parents you see how wrong it is? This is a very biased judgment
Just because Google maintains chromium doesn’t mean that chromium browsers have to track you.
You are 100% correct but some can’t accept that.
Also Brave provides a list of the changes they make in Chromium, and it’s an open-source browser, and the cryptocurrency stuff that you can easily disable and hide doesn’t take away anything from this.
I should note that I switched back to Firefox today not because it is better (it is not better, it is better in some aspects, privacy, and performance not being one of them), but because I won’t just sit and watch Google having a full monopoly over the internet, we saw and still seeing what they are willing to do when they have full control over the internet (manifest v3 and WEI), this is me doing what I can against Google’s monopoly as using a chromium-based browser does contribute to their monopoly, you can say this won’t change much I’ll say I don’t care because I believe it is still the right thing to do, I’ll do the right thing even if it won’t change much
